In fact, they did not seem comfortable using the word revision and explained that revision. But i do know that this article was talking about the different revision strategies that could be used to help new and experienced writers. Responding to student writers, 1st edition macmillan. In the writing classroom, however, revision is treated as a noncreative act, a polishing act concerned with taking the linguistic litter out of sentences. Some might say that the rhetorical situation, an expression coined by lloyd bitzer, is the most important concept in writing.
Nancy sommers revision strategies of student writers and. Nancy sommerss revision strategies of student writers and. Remote work advice from the largest allremote company. Environmental education resources to commemorate earth days 50th anniversary. I love sommerss call to focus on the broad purpose of commenting rather than the minutiae of corrections. Sep 19, 2012 nancy sommers s revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers as i read this text, one thing was certain. Writers and experienced adult writers, ccc, 31 december. I dont think ive ever found a necessary grammar or style concept that it lacked. Nancy sommers, who has taught composition and directed composition programs for thirty years, now teaches in harvards graduate school of education. Revising your paper why and how to revise most of us who compose on a computer understand revision as an ongoing, even constant process.
The 4s method for helping students revise their writing a. Look at 8 strategies for critically engaging sources and discuss which one your own paper most closely resembles and why. Nov 24, 2014 english 3100 20thcentury composition theory and practice. Eric ed220839 revision strategies of student writers and. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers selected excerpts from complete article nancy sommers revision strategies of student writers 1 most of the students i studied did not use the terms revision or rewriting. Pdf perspectives revision in second language writing. I n the writing classroom, however, revision is treated as a noncreative act, a polishing act concerned with taking the linguistic litter out of sentences. In this strategy, the writers who usually follow these rules are considered student writers in sommers essay.
Download this handout pdf introduction youve written a full draft of an argumentative paper. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult. She led harvards expository writing program for twenty years, directing the firstyear writing program and establishing harvards wac program. To describe and analyze the revision processes of a group of college freshmen and a group of experienced adult writers, eight freshman students and seven experienced adult writers were asked to write three compositions, rewrite each composition two times, suggest revisions for a composition written by an anonymous author, and be interviewed three times. Sommers responding to student writing summary at the beginning of the lecture sommer says, commenting on student writing is the most widely used method for responding to student writing, it is the least understood 148. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers. Sommers revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers summary sommer s lecture called revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers starts with words of the author, the reason for this, i suspect, is that current models of writing process have directed attention away from revision 378. The author is trying to show the reader that there are different theories between writers on rewriting an assignment, and that. Writing about writing, 3rd edition macmillan learning. The overall message of responding to student writers is fresh and relevant an important reminder to reflect and revisit our role in the revision process. The revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers.
Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers nancy sommers. Week 3 nancy sommers revision strategies english 12. Nancy sommers reading response my senior exit portfolio. Pocket style manual, 8th edition macmillan learning for. Document resume ed 220 839 cs 207 146 author sommers, nancy title revision strategies of student writers and. Nancy sommers, revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers. Sommers revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers summary sommers lecture called revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers starts with words of the author, the reason for this, i suspect, is that current models of writing process have directed attention away from revision 378. In the writing classroom, however, revision is treated as a noncreative act, a polishing act concerned with taking the linguistic litter out of. Nancy sommers s revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers 1980 defines revision not as a separate, final stage of writing but as a sequence of changes in a compositionchanges which are initiated by cues and occur continually throughout the writing of a work 45. In this strategy, the writers who usually follow these rules are considered student writers in sommer s essay.
The planning strategies of a publishing writer, and donald m. When you revise and are spending time thinking about how well your content works in your essay, there are some strategies to keep in mind that can help. Revising an argumentative paper the writing center uw. What nancy sommers revision strategies, peter elbows more ways to revise, from writing with power, or carley moores available in texts folder. The reason for this, i suspect, is that current models of the writing process have directed. Nancy sommerss revision strategies of student writers. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers sommers, nancy i on. A pocket style manual is more than just another textbookits a tool for the students. Revision is thus a difficult writing practice to teach due to both instructor.
Between the drafts nancy sommers i cannot think of my childhood without hearing voices, deep, heavilyaccented, instructive german voices. Try walking around the room as you read your revision notes. Responding to student writing nancy sommers college. This point made by sommer will make the teacher and student work as a team and the results will be better. In the article revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers the author nancy sommers is interested in knowing more about how students approach revision and how experts interpret revision. She discovered that as a revision strategy, students often demonstrated a thesaurus philosophy of writing, meaning the students believe that most problems in their essays can be solved by rewording 381. Sommers completed a case study with students and experienced writers. Nancy sommers harvard graduate school of education. Scholarly articles by nancy sommers the macmillan community. Nancy sommers intentions and revisions outside the writing classroom, the word revision suggests a process of change, one of reseeing and reconceptualizing. She found that student writers are more concerned with. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers nancy sommers although various aspects. Sommers is an internationally recognized leader in the field of writing studies and a prizewinning writer.
First, a rhetorical situation includes what he calls an exigence, or occasion for writing. How teachers and students can make the quick transition to online learning. Eric ed220839 revision strategies of student writers. Strategies for peer group and individual conferencing kathy evertz, director, academic support center, carleton college. Revision strategies sommers revision strategies of. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers nancy sommers although various aspects of the writing process have been studied exten sively of late, research on revision has been notably absent. And the examples are incredibly helpful for students. When taught how to use the book like a tool, the students are empowered to be active writers. Designed by writing teachers frustrated by a lack of technology to support their work, every feature in eli is grounded in writing and learning theory. Although, as sommers 1982 puts forward, for most students revision is an. Nancy sommers intentions and revisions revision suggests a.
Nancy sommers, revision strategies of student writers and. The reason for this, i suspect, is that current models of the writing process have directed attention away from revision. Nancy sommerss revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers. Request a sample or learn about ordering options for writing about writing, 3rd edition by elizabeth wardle from the macmillan learning instructor catalog. Pocket style manual 8th edition diana hacker macmillan.
I hear the voice of my father reading to me from struvelpater, the german childrens tale about a messy boy who refuses to cut his hair or his fingernails. Discusses the revision strategies of experienced writers, showing that the writing process is recursive rather than linear. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Although various aspects of the writing process have been studied exten. Linear revision strategy fails to include actual revisions.
Nancy sommers examined the revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers 1980 nancy sommers two main writing process models are based on speech and have no revisions rohman. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced. The author challenges us not only to dismiss the notion of revision as a dirty word, but to embrace it as an essential and fruitful tool that could, and should be an important part of the writing process. Seeing beyond hearing is the point to make revision a lot easier and effective. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adulthriters nancy sommers although various aspects of the writing process have been studied exten sively of late, research on revision has been notably absent. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers responding to student writing between the drafts.
Sommers definition of of a linear revision strategy is one that involves three steps, prewriting, writing, and rewriting 75. Murray response of a laboratory rat or, being protocoled 72 anne lamott shitty first drafts 74 nancy sommers revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers75 supplemental activities for chapter 5 76. She ends her essay with a call to encourage student writers to see writing as a discovery process, as a repeated process of seeing, and then seeing again. Youve figured out what youre generally saying and have put together one way to say it. One way to see what in a text needs to be revised, of course, is by. Her articles revision strategies of student and experienced writers and responding to student writing are two of the most widely read and. Document resume cs 207 146 sommers, nancy revision. Porters intertextuality and the discourse community week 8 jim corder argument as emergence, rhetoric as love. Revising an argumentative paper the writing center uwmadison. Sommers now teaches at harvards graduate school of education, where she leads a teachers as writers initiative. After you have completed your revision, put away all your notes and ask a friend to test you on what you have learned. College composition and communication publishes research and scholarship in rhetoric and composition studies that supports college teachers in reflecting on and improving their practices in teaching writing and that reflects the most current scholarship and theory in the field.
Although various aspects of the writing process have been studied extensively of late, research on revision has been notably absent. According to bitzer, all writing occurs within a rhetorical situation, and every rhetorical situation has three components. With linda simon, she has written the forthcoming harpercollins guide to writing. In one point of this essay sommers stated that revision is not a word that students used, that is was a word used by their teachers. Most of the students i studied did not use the terms revision.
The purpose of sommers article is to point out to the reader how students view revision and how experienced writers portray revision. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers nancy sommers l though various aspects of the writing process have been studied extensively of late, research on revision has been notably absent. Sommers shares her findings on the subject after questioning both student an. There are variations of this description of revision, but all involve a sequence of activity. The intersections of revision and emotion since nancy sommers s landmark contribution, revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers, appeared over forty years without an outlet for the fear or strategies. Outside the writing classroom, the word revision suggests a process of change, one of reseeing andreconceptualizing. Eric ej240356 revision strategies of student writers and. Pdf revision strategies of student writers and experienced.
The instant feedback can preclude deep thinking about revision. In order to offer a useful revision strategy to a student. The field of composition studies draws on research and theories from a broad range of humanistic. Nancy sommers s revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers as i read this text, one thing was certain. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers responding to student writing between the drafts i stand here writing the language of coats. In a short reflective essay, i address the content of theory and practice in nancy sommers revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers, in which i read and articulated the article in connection to the course text and class discussions. Richardson 125, a practice only for remedial writers downs 67, or a form of punishment horning 2.
File uploaded by nancy sommers expert on jul 1, 2015last modified by karita dos santos on sep 4, 2015. Revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers college composition and communication, december 1980 as the author explores perceptions about revision, she asks us to consider, why should revision be forgotten. Nancy sommers although various aspects of the writing process have been studied exten sively of late, research on revision has been notably absent. Some thoughts and suggestions for writingbased course. Her articles revision strategies of student and experienced writers, responding to student writing, and between the drafts are three of the most widely read and anthologized articles in the field. Effective revision strategies what the research says higher effectiveness regular practice testing distributed practice short sessions moderate effectiveness elaborative interrogation turning facts to be learned into whyquestions and then answering them self explanation explaining to yourself what you are doing and. Every time you hit the delete button, every time you cut and paste, every time you take out a comma or exchange one word for another, youre revising. Sommers shares her findings on the subject after questioning both student and teacher writers alike, asking them to explain what revision means to them.
A pocket style manual is both comprehensive and concise, which is difficult to achieve. In these linear conceptions of the writing process revision is understood as a separate stage at the end of the processa stage that comes after the completion of a first or second draft and one that is temporally distinct from the prewriting and writing stages of the process. This is a good way to make revision more interactive. Explores the flaws in linear theories of the writing process and student writers attitudes toward revision that these theories reinforce. Sommers ends the article by stating that all writers should see their writing as with their own eyes. Responding to student writing week 3 nancy sommers revision strategies week 4 brummett three meanings of epistemic rhetoric. Nancy sommers in her article revision strategies of student writers and experienced adult writers, sums it up this way. First and foremost, during the revision process, you should seek outside feedback. Nancy sommers, whose most recent essay in ccc appeared in the december, 1980. A case study of the connection between extracurricular and academic writings marissa penzato produced in elizabeth wardles fall 2011 enc1102 t. Sommers responding to student writing summary and synthesis.
792 12 1115 504 796 1197 525 314 1457 1043 127 1450 1438 34 821 164 770 746 47 522 1238 351 1387 505 1493 5 1402 1205 253 1440 1348 464 63 813